How To Write A Murder Mystery (Plot, Clues & Red Herrings) | Self Pub Hub

"The first draft is just you telling yourself the story," Stephen King once said. That's doubly true for a murder mystery. The real magic happens when you figure out how to tell that story to someone else, piece by tantalizing piece. A whodunit isn't a linear story. It's a puzzle, a clockwork machine of secrets, lies, and misdirection that needs to click perfectly into place on the final page.

The mystery genre is a perennial bestseller, with thrillers and crime novels always finding an audience. Readers are hungry for a new puzzle to solve. This guide covers the key parts of plotting, character, and deception you'll need to build a mystery that keeps readers guessing until the final page.

How to Write a Murder Mystery: The Backward Approach

Most stories are written from A to B. Murder mysteries are the exception. The best way to build a whodunit that actually holds together is to start at the end and work your way backward.

Before you type a single word of chapter one, you need to know the absolute truth of the crime.

Define Your Solution First:

1. The Killer: Who did it? Choose one of your characters.
2. The Motive: Why did they do it? This needs to be powerful: Greed, revenge, passion, fear. A weak motive makes the entire story fall apart.
3. The Method: How did they do it? Get specific. What was the weapon? How did they create an alibi? How did they cover their tracks?
4. The Opportunity: When and where did the murder happen, and how was the killer able to be there without being caught immediately?

Once you have these four points locked down, you have the "truth." Your job as the author is to build a maze of lies, distractions, and half-truths to hide that solution from the reader. Every clue and red herring you place will be designed to point both towards and away from this central truth.

Plotting backward prevents you from writing yourself into a corner. It guarantees that your ending is not just a surprise, but an inevitability. When the detective finally puts the pieces together, the reader should feel like the answer was right in front of them the whole time. You can explore different plotting methods, like those in the Plottr visual outlining software, to help map this out.

The Golden Rule: Playing Fair with Your Reader

The contract between a mystery writer and their reader rests on one simple rule: Fair Play.

This means every clue needed to solve the crime must be on the page for the reader to find. Think of the reader as your detective's silent partner. They deserve a fighting chance to figure it out. If your detective cracks the case using information he learned "off-screen" or a clue you never mentioned, your reader will feel cheated.

The goal is to hide your clues in plain sight.

• Bury a critical detail in a long list of mundane items.
• Have a character mention something vital, but in a context that makes it seem unimportant.
• Present a physical clue, but let the detective (and the reader) draw the wrong conclusion about its meaning.

An unfair clue, on the other hand, is information that is withheld entirely. For example, revealing the killer is the victim's secret identical twin who was never mentioned before the final chapter. That’s not a twist; it’s a betrayal of the reader's trust. The "aha!" moment is the reward for their attention to detail. Don't rob them of it.

Free AI Writing Tool

Stop Staring at a Blank Page

Publy is a distraction-free book editor with AI built in. Brainstorm plot ideas, get instant chapter reviews, or rewrite clunky paragraphs. 3 million free words included.

AI Chat + Ideas Review + Rewrite Export PDF

Start Writing Free

Crafting Your Cast of Characters

A mystery is nothing without its people. The victim, the suspects, and the detective are the engine of your story.

The Detective: More Than Just a Magnifying Glass

Your protagonist doesn't have to be a grizzled police officer or a pipe-smoking private eye. They can be a baker, a librarian, or a nosy teenager. What matters is their motivation.

• Give Them a Reason: Why are they, specifically, driven to solve this crime? Maybe the victim was a loved one. Maybe they were wrongly accused themselves. A personal stake is always more compelling than simple professional duty.
• Give Them Flaws: A perfect detective is boring. Are they stubborn? Reckless? Too trusting? Their flaws should create complications during the investigation. Perhaps they overlook a key clue because of a personal bias.
• Give Them a Unique Voice: How do they see the world? Their internal monologue and observations are the reader's window into the mystery. Make their perspective interesting. You can use their unique worldview to write a story that feels like only they could tell it, much like how you would write a story that will make someone cry by zeroing in on a raw emotional truth.

The Suspects: A Lineup of Lies

A common mistake new writers make is having too few suspects (the killer is obvious) or too many (the reader can't keep track). What most people get wrong here is the balance. The sweet spot is around five to six viable suspects. This is enough to create doubt without being overwhelming.

For each suspect, you must develop three key elements:

1. Motive: Each suspect should have a plausible reason for wanting the victim dead.
2. Means: Could they have physically committed the crime? Did they have access to the weapon or location?
3. Opportunity: Where were they at the time of the murder? If they have an alibi, make it shaky.

Here's the key: give every suspect a secret that has nothing to do with the murder. This is a fantastic tool for misdirection. One suspect lies about their alibi not because they were killing someone, but because they were having an affair. Another hides a financial problem out of shame, not because it's a motive for murder. These secondary secrets make your characters feel like real people and generate natural red herrings.

The Victim: Make the Reader Care

The victim is more than a plot device. To create emotional stakes, the victim needs to feel like a real person whose absence leaves a hole in the world. Explore their life through flashbacks or the memories of other characters.

What secrets were they keeping? Who loved them? Who hated them? The more complex and contradictory the victim's life was, the more interesting the motives for their murder will become. The investigation should not just uncover a killer, but also the secret life of the person who was killed.

The Art of Deception: Planting Clues and Red Herrings

The whole game of a murder mystery is the dance between revealing and hiding information. You do this with clues and their evil twins: red herrings.

Planting Clues in Fiction (The Breadcrumb Trail)

Clues are the verifiable facts that, when correctly interpreted, point to the killer. Your job is to sprinkle them throughout the narrative without a giant neon sign pointing at them.

Types of Clues to Use:

• Physical Clues: A dropped button, a muddy footprint, a misplaced object, a specific type of poison.
• Dialogue Clues: A slip of the tongue, a lie that can be disproven, an oddly specific denial, a piece of information a person shouldn't know.
• Psychological Clues: A suspect's unusual reaction to a question, a pattern of behavior, a known phobia or obsession that becomes relevant.

The best clues often have a double meaning. A love letter found in the victim's desk might seem to point to a jealous spouse, but upon closer inspection, the handwriting matches a different suspect entirely. The initial, obvious interpretation works as misdirection. Hiding the real meaning is the secret to a great plot twist that surprises readers.

Weaving a Web of Red Herrings

A red herring is a clue that is intentionally misleading. It’s designed to make an innocent person look guilty and send the detective (and the reader) down the wrong path. But for a red herring to be effective, it must be logical and plausible.

A bad red herring is based on coincidence. For example, Suspect A just happens to own the same rare type of knife used in the murder. That feels like a cheap trick.

A good red herring is based on the character's secrets. Suspect A is seen sneaking away from the victim's house at night. This looks incredibly guilty. But the reason is that he was retrieving incriminating photos from an affair he was having with the victim's wife. His actions were suspicious, but they had an innocent (in the context of murder) explanation.

The best red herrings make the reader feel smart for falling for them. They should be convinced they’ve solved the crime, right before you pull the rug out from under them with the true, innocent explanation. Frankly, this is the most important part of any guide for an aspiring mystery writer.

Spreadsheet

The Self-Publishing Launch Checklist (2026)

A week-by-week spreadsheet that walks you through every step of launching your book. Available as an Excel file and Google Sheet.

8-week pre-launch plan Launch day battle plan Post-launch tracker

Download Sheet

Structuring Your Whodunit Plot

The writing process can be messy, but a classic mystery structure provides a solid skeleton for your story.

The Discovery (The Inciting Incident)

This is the event that kicks off the story: the murder. Editors often look for a body to be discovered within the first thirty pages. A long prologue or extensive backstory can kill momentum before the story even begins. Present the puzzle to the reader as quickly as possible. The current boom in domestic suspense, as noted in publishing trend analyses, often hinges on this immediate disruption of normal life.

The Investigation (The Rising Action)

This is the bulk of your novel. The detective begins their work, interviewing suspects, examining the crime scene, and gathering clues. Each chapter should move the investigation forward. A common mistake is the "sagging middle," where the plot stalls out. To avoid this, make sure every scene reveals new information, introduces a fresh complication, or eliminates a possibility. Learning how to write dialogue that sounds natural is critical here, since interviews and interrogations are what move the story forward.

The Midpoint Twist

Around the halfway point of the book, introduce a major revelation that changes everything the detective (and reader) thought they knew. Another body might drop. The prime suspect's alibi could be proven solid. A key piece of evidence could be revealed as a fake. This twist re-energizes the story and raises the stakes for the second half.

The Final Reveal (The Climax)

This is the moment everyone has been waiting for. It can be the classic "gathering all the suspects in the library" scene or a tense one-on-one confrontation between the detective and the killer. The detective lays out the timeline, explains the clues, debunks the red herrings, and finally points their finger at the guilty party.

The Resolution

After the killer is revealed, there's a short period of falling action. The detective explains any remaining loose ends, like the real reasons behind the red herrings. This is also where the emotional impact of the crime is processed. Justice has been served, but at what cost? This provides a satisfying conclusion for the reader. Considering the legal aspects of your story, particularly if it's based on real events, might also be worth a look, similar to a memoir legal checklist.

Finding Your Niche: Popular Murder Mystery Sub-Genres

The term "murder mystery" covers a wide range of styles and tones. Choosing a sub-genre helps you meet reader expectations and find your audience.

These aren't rigid boxes. Many authors mix things up, creating a police procedural with a noir detective or a cozy mystery set in a big city. The point is to understand the basic promise of each sub-genre so you can give its fans the story they're looking for. For instance, knowing how to handle illustrations is as important as the text, so it's smart to be clear on whether it's okay to use clipart in your book.

Common Beginner Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Writing your first mystery is a learning process. Here are some common traps and how to sidestep them.

• The Info-Dump Beginning: Starting with pages of character backstory or setting description. The Fix: Start with the crime. Weave in backstory later, as it becomes relevant to the investigation.
• The Sagging Middle: Chapters where nothing happens except the detective thinking about the case. The Fix: Create a plot point for every chapter. A new clue, a suspect's lie exposed, a threat to the detective. Always keep the story moving.
• The Villain Monologue: The killer conveniently confesses everything in a long speech. The Fix: The detective should solve the crime through deduction. The final confrontation is for confirmation and catharsis, not exposition.
• Indistinguishable Suspects: All your suspects sound and act the same. The Fix: Give each suspect a unique voice, a distinct personality, and a specific secret they are trying to protect.
• The "And Then I Woke Up" Solution: The ending relies on a wild coincidence, a dream, or information the reader never had. The Fix: Stick to the rule of Fair Play. The solution must be solvable with the clues you provided. You might also want to explore different publishing options for your book, comparing services like KDP vs. IngramSpark for hardcover editions.

Writing a murder mystery is a challenge, but it’s one of the most rewarding genres out there. It’s a puzzle and a story rolled into one. If you start with your solution, play fair with your audience, and master the art of misdirection, you can write a whodunit that will have readers tearing through every page.