10 Things to Do When You’re Stuck on Your Plot

Most writers assume a plot hole is a sign of failure. It is actually just a sign that your characters have started to outgrow the box you put them in. When you hit a narrative wall where the logic falls apart, it feels like the story is broken. But this is usually where the story gets interesting. You are not just patching a leak. You are forcing the story to become smarter than the reader expected.

If you are looking for things to do when you're stuck on your plot, realize that hitting a narrative wall often means the story is about to get interesting.

Readers today are sharper than ever. Audiences trained on decades of complex TV dramas and intricate video game lore will spot a continuity error in seconds. They discuss these flaws on Reddit forums and Goodreads reviews with ruthless efficiency. If you want to keep them immersed, you have to tighten the screws on your narrative structure.

What Are Plot Holes and Why Do They Happen?

A plot hole is not just a scene you dislike. It is a gap in logic that breaks the rules you established for your own world. It pulls the reader out of the experience because the suspension of disbelief shatters.

You told them the magic sword glows when orcs are near. Now the orcs are here, and the sword is dim. The reader stops trusting you.

These narrative gaps usually fall into three specific buckets.

The Logic Gap

This is the most common offender. Event A leads to Event B, but Event B makes Event C impossible.

For example, your protagonist is locked in a high-security prison cell without a key. In the next scene, they are running through the forest. If you do not explain how they got out, you have a logic gap. Readers will not fill in that blank for you. They will just assume you forgot.

The Character Contradiction

Characters must drive the plot, not the other way around. A massive plot hole opens up when a character does something completely out of character just because the author needs the story to move forward.

If your hero is established as a pacifist who faints at the sight of blood, they cannot suddenly pick up a machine gun and mow down a room of bad guys just because you need them to escape. This breaks the emotional contract you made with the reader.

The Timeline Fracture

In complex stories, keeping track of time is a nightmare. You might have a subplot that takes three days to resolve, while the main plot only takes three hours.

When those two storylines merge, the math does not add up. A character cannot be in London for breakfast and Tokyo for lunch without a very fast plane or a teleportation device.

Spreadsheet

The Self-Publishing Launch Checklist (2026)

A week-by-week spreadsheet that walks you through every step of launching your book. Available as an Excel file and Google Sheet.

8-week pre-launch plan Launch day battle plan Post-launch tracker

Download Sheet

10 Things to Do When You're Stuck

When you stare at your draft and realize the math doesn't work, do not panic. Do not delete the manuscript. Use these ten specific strategies to bridge the gap.

1. The "Raymond Chandler" Maneuver

When in doubt, have a man come through the door with a gun. It is old advice because it works.

If your plot is stuck or feels full of holes because nothing is happening, introduce an immediate, high-stakes threat. This forces characters to react instinctively. It clears away the over-complicated logic that created the hole in the first place. You can explain the "why" later. Right now, you just need to move the pieces on the board.

2. Work Backward from the Solution

If you know where the character needs to end up but the bridge to get there is broken, stop writing forward. Start at the destination. Write the scene where they arrive.

Then ask: "What had to happen five minutes before this?" Then five minutes before that.

This reverse engineering highlights exactly where the logic snaps. You might realize the hole isn't in the current chapter, but in a decision made ten chapters ago. To learn how to write an outline for a book effectively, you often need to perform this reverse check before you even start the first draft. It saves you from painting yourself into a corner.

3. Interview Your Characters

If a character’s action creates a plot hole, sit them down. Write a monologue where they explain why they did what they did.

You might find that the character has a motivation you hadn't considered. Maybe they let the villain escape on purpose. Suddenly, what looked like a plot hole is now a layer of intrigue.

4. The "Lampshade" Technique

Sometimes you cannot fix the hole without rewriting the entire book. In this case, hang a lampshade on it. Have a character acknowledge the absurdity.

• Character A: "Wait, how did you get past the security cameras?"
• Character B: "I honestly have no idea. We got lucky. Let's move."

By acknowledging the improbability, you validate the reader's skepticism. You are telling them, "I know this is weird, bear with me." It buys you a lot of goodwill.

5. Use the "Rule of Cool" (With Caution)

If the result of the plot hole is awesome enough, readers might ignore the logic. This is risky. But if the inconsistency leads to the best fight scene or the most emotional reunion in the book, keep it. Just make sure the payoff is worth the logical cost.

6. Leverage AI for Continuity Checks

Technology has shifted. We now have tools that can track entities better than our own brains. Writers can use AI to scan chapters and list every location a character visits. You can ask an LLM, "Is there any point where John uses the knife he lost in Chapter 3?"

According to recent analysis on AI in storytelling, Large Language Models themselves can introduce plot holes when generating text, with detection rates of these errors rising significantly. However, when used as a diagnostic tool rather than a writer, they are incredibly effective at flagging timeline errors humans miss.

7. Create a Visual Timeline

Stop typing and start drawing. Get a whiteboard or use a digital tool like Aeon Timeline. Map out every single scene chronologically.

Do this by day and hour, not by chapter. You will spot the gaps immediately. You will see that your hero spent 48 hours awake without sleeping, or that a letter arrived before it was mailed.

8. Stress Test with Beta Readers

You are too close to the work. You know what you meant to write, so your brain fills in the gaps. A reader does not have that luxury. Send your chapters to a trusted group. Do not ask them "Do you like it?" Ask them "What didn't make sense?"

To get the best results, you need to ask the right things. Using specific questions for beta readers will help you pinpoint exactly where the narrative chain breaks. If three people ask the same question about how the magic system works, you have a plot hole.

9. Kill Your Darlings (The Subtraction Method)

Sometimes a plot hole exists because you are trying to force a scene that doesn't belong. You love the scene. It has great dialogue. But it contradicts the rest of the book.

The fix isn't to add more explanation. The fix is to cut the scene. When you remove the contradictory element, the hole often closes itself.

10. Turn the Bug into a Feature

This is the advanced move. If there is a massive inconsistency, make it a central mystery of the plot. Why doesn't the magic sword glow? Maybe the sword is a fake. Maybe the orcs aren't really orcs. By leaning into the error, you turn a mistake into a plot twist.

If you are looking for inspiration on how to twist a story, check out our guide on 10 Plot Twist Ideas That Will Shock Your Readers.

The Role of AI in Finding and Fixing Holes

The landscape of writing has changed. We need to talk about how technology impacts narrative structure. In the past, you needed a professional editor to catch these slips. Now, software plays a massive role.

New data suggests that while AI is great at structure, it struggles with long-form consistency on its own. It tends to "forget" details from earlier in the conversation. However, tools designed specifically for fiction writers are bridging this gap. These platforms allow you to input your "story bible" (your rules, characters, and settings) and then check new text against that database.

This is not about letting a computer write your book. It is about using a machine to handle the data management so you can focus on the art. We explore this dynamic further in our article asking can AI replace writers, which breaks down the limits of current technology.

If you are looking for a dedicated tool to help map out these complexities, software like Plottr or Scrivener is essential. You can visualize the threads before they tangle.

Common Traps That Create Holes

Knowing how to fix them is good. Knowing how to avoid them is better. Most narrative jams come from a lack of preparation.

The "Pantser" Problem

Writers who "fly by the seat of their pants" (discovery writers) are prone to plot holes. They make up rules in Chapter 3 that they forget by Chapter 12. If you write this way, your revision phase will be much longer. You have to go back and retrofit the logic.

The Over-Powered Protagonist

If your hero is too strong, you have to invent stupid reasons for them to fail. This creates holes. "Why didn't Superman just use his super speed?" is a question that has plagued comic book writers for decades.

Keep your characters limited. Limits create tension. Infinite power creates logic gaps.

The Magic System Without Costs

If magic can do anything, then every problem should be solvable instantly. If it isn't, you have a plot hole. You must establish what magic cannot do. The limitations are more important than the capabilities.

If you are planning a multi-book saga, these issues multiply. You need to create a successful book series by planning the arching limitations early. If the rules change between Book 1 and Book 2, you lose the reader.

Free AI Writing Tool

Stop Staring at a Blank Page

Publy is a distraction-free book editor with AI built in. Brainstorm plot ideas, get instant chapter reviews, or rewrite clunky paragraphs. 3 million free words included.

AI Chat + Ideas Review + Rewrite Export PDF

Start Writing Free

Prevention: The Story Bible

The best defense against a plot hole is a good offense. You need a Story Bible. This is a document separate from your manuscript where you record every fact about your world.

• Character Profiles: Eye color, birthday, fears, major life events.
• World Rules: How fast does travel work? What is the currency? What are the laws of physics/magic?
• Timeline: A master calendar of events.

When you are writing Chapter 20 and you can't remember if it's Tuesday or Thursday, you check the Bible. You don't guess. Guessing leads to holes.

According to Sudowrite's analysis of writing workflows, using an AI assistant that acts as a "tireless, detail-obsessed" partner to maintain this bible is becoming a standard industry practice. It helps maintain the "connective tissue" of a story that might otherwise fray over 300 pages.

Handling Audience Feedback

Eventually, you will miss something. A book goes to print, and a reader finds a hole. It happens to the best. J.K. Rowling has them. Stephen King has them.

When a reader points out a plot hole in a published work, you have two choices. You can ignore it, or you can address it in the sequel. Do not get defensive.

Reader discussions, like those found on Reddit forums discussing film inconsistencies, show that audiences enjoy the "hunt" for these errors. It engages them. Sometimes, a plot hole generates more theory videos and blog posts than the actual plot.

Advanced Narrative Structures

If you want to avoid linear plot holes, consider changing the structure of your story. A non-linear narrative can hide a lot of sins. By jumping around in time, you rely less on direct cause-and-effect chains and more on thematic resonance.

However, this is a high-wire act. If you mess up a non-linear timeline, the plot holes become confusing rather than just annoying.

For those struggling to get the basics down first, start with our guide on The Beginner's Guide to Writing Your First Chapter. It helps set the tone so logic flows naturally from page one.

Using "Deus Ex Machina" Correctly

A "Deus Ex Machina" (God from the Machine) is the opposite of a plot hole, but it is just as damaging. It is when you solve a problem out of nowhere. The cavalry arrives just in time. The bomb fails to detonate for no reason.

While this fixes the immediate "hole" of how the hero survives, it creates a "logic hole" regarding the stakes. Readers feel cheated.

The solution? Set up the save early. If the cavalry is going to arrive in Chapter 30, we need to see them saddle up in Chapter 5. This turns a cheat into a payoff.

Troubleshooting: Solutions for Narrative Jams

If you are stuck right now, try this exercise. It is called the "But/Therefore" method, popularized by the creators of South Park.

Look at your outline. If you can connect your scenes with the words "And then," you have a boring story that is prone to holes.

• "He went to the store, AND THEN he bought milk, AND THEN he went home."

Replace "And then" with "Therefore" or "But."

• "He went to the store, BUT it was closed. THEREFORE, he had to break in."

This causality tightens the plot. It makes every action a direct result of the previous one. It leaves no room for holes because the chain of logic is unbroken.

If you are still hitting walls, you might be dealing with writer's block disguised as a plot problem. Check out 7 Simple Tricks to Beat Writer's Block Today to see if the issue is mental rather than structural.

Wrapping Up

Plot holes are annoying, but they are fixable. They are usually just symptoms of a story that is trying to be bigger than its current structure allows. By stepping back, using modern tools, and trusting your characters, you can patch the holes and make the story stronger.

Do not fear the red pen. The only way to fix a hole is to fill it with something better.